Tin Missile Trophy Sportsfishing
HomeTrips & RatesGalleryReviewsFishing ReportsTarget SpeciesMeet the Captain

Learn More

My Trips

Premier Lake Ontario Walleye Fishing Charter

  • Published Date: July 17, 2025
  • Fishing
  • Lake Ontario
  • $450 - $895 price range

Summary

Join us for an evening Walleye fishing trip on Lake Ontario that's all about landing that trophy catch. We're after the big ones - 30 inches or more! Our 4-hour outing starts at 4:30 PM, giving you prime time to hook into some serious fish. While Walleye is our main target, don't be surprised if you tangle with some hefty Northern Pike or hard-fighting Smallmouth Bass along the way. This charter is perfect for anglers who want quality over quantity, focusing on outsmarting those elusive lake monsters. Our experienced crew knows all the hotspots and techniques to put you on fish. We'll cruise the scenic waters, dropping lines in prime locations as the sun starts to dip. Whether you're a seasoned pro or new to trophy fishing, you'll love the challenge and excitement of battling these freshwater giants. Bring your camera - you might just snap a photo with the catch of a lifetime!
Premier Lake Ontario Walleye Fishing Charter

Monster Walleye Moments

previous-image
Two big fish caught in Sackets Harbor

Best days are spent fishing Lake Ontario.

Lone angler fishing in New York

Lake Ontario magic: big catches, better views.

8 rainbow trout and chinook salmon in Sackets Harbor

A day on Lake Ontario is well spent.

Two 45-inch fish caught while fishing in NY

Hooked on the beauty of Lake Ontario.

Two Coho Salmon, each measuring 29 inches, being caught while fishing in NY

Reeling in memories on Lake Ontario.

Three Chinook Salmon fish caught during fishing outing in New York

Catching fish and making stories on Lake Ontario.

Angler catching a large Chinook Salmon in Sackets Harbor

The waters of Lake Ontario always call.

Angler holding a large lake trout caught while fishing at Sackets Harbor

A perfect day on Lake Ontario: great fishing.

Chinook Salmon fish caught in NY

Lake Ontario’s calm waters hiding big fish.

Three chinook and coho salmon caught in Sackets Harbor

Nothing beats Lake Ontario at first light.

Two big fish caught in Sackets Harbor

Best days are spent fishing Lake Ontario.

Lone angler fishing in New York

Lake Ontario magic: big catches, better views.

8 rainbow trout and chinook salmon in Sackets Harbor

A day on Lake Ontario is well spent.

Two 45-inch fish caught while fishing in NY

Hooked on the beauty of Lake Ontario.

Two Coho Salmon, each measuring 29 inches, being caught while fishing in NY

Reeling in memories on Lake Ontario.

Three Chinook Salmon fish caught during fishing outing in New York

Catching fish and making stories on Lake Ontario.

Angler catching a large Chinook Salmon in Sackets Harbor

The waters of Lake Ontario always call.

Angler holding a large lake trout caught while fishing at Sackets Harbor

A perfect day on Lake Ontario: great fishing.

Chinook Salmon fish caught in NY

Lake Ontario’s calm waters hiding big fish.

Three chinook and coho salmon caught in Sackets Harbor

Nothing beats Lake Ontario at first light.

Two big fish caught in Sackets Harbor

Best days are spent fishing Lake Ontario.

Lone angler fishing in New York

Lake Ontario magic: big catches, better views.

8 rainbow trout and chinook salmon in Sackets Harbor

A day on Lake Ontario is well spent.

Two 45-inch fish caught while fishing in NY

Hooked on the beauty of Lake Ontario.

next-image

Lake Ontario's Trophy Walleye Adventure

Ready for a shot at landing a monster walleye on Lake Ontario? Our evening charter puts you right in the thick of the action when these prized fish are most active. We're not after quantity here - this trip is all about quality, giving you the best chance to hook into that 30-inch-plus walleye of a lifetime. With the sun setting over the lake and the anticipation building, there's nothing quite like the thrill of feeling that big hit on your line. And hey, while we're focused on walleye, don't be surprised if a feisty pike or hard-fighting smallmouth decides to crash the party. It's all part of the excitement out here on Ontario's waters!

What's the Deal?

Picture this: You're out on the boat as the day winds down, the lake's surface glowing with the last rays of sunlight. That's when the big walleyes start to get hungry. Our 4-hour trip kicks off at 4:30 PM, prime time for trophy walleye action. We've got room for 3 anglers, so bring your buddies or make it a family outing. Just a heads up - we don't provide food on this one, so maybe pack a few snacks to keep your energy up while you're reeling in the big ones. Trust me, when that rod bends over with a heavy fish, you'll be glad you fueled up!

Tactics for Trophies

Alright, let's talk strategy. Evening fishing for walleye isn't your run-of-the-mill trolling trip. We'll be using a mix of techniques depending on what the fish are telling us. Might be slow-trolling with deep-diving crankbaits, or maybe we'll set up a drift and work the bottom with live bait rigs. Jigs tipped with minnows or nightcrawlers? You bet - that's a walleye classic for a reason. We've got all the gear you need, from sensitive rods to fish-finding electronics. Your job is to stay alert and be ready to set the hook when that telltale tap-tap comes through the line. It's all about reading the water, adjusting to conditions, and putting you on the fish. That's what we do best.

Species You'll Want to Hook

Walleye are the stars of this show, and for good reason. These golden-eyed predators are some of the tastiest fish swimming, but on this trip, we're after the photo op and the thrill of the fight. A trophy walleye in Lake Ontario can push past 30 inches and weigh over 10 pounds. They've got a reputation for being finnicky, but when they bite, hold on tight! Best time to target them? You're looking at it - that evening bite when they move up to feed is hard to beat.

Northern Pike are the aggressive cousins crashing our walleye party. These toothy missiles can top 40 inches in Ontario's waters. They're ambush predators, often lurking in weed beds or along drop-offs. When a pike hits, it's not subtle - be ready for a drag-screaming run and some acrobatics at the boat.

Smallmouth Bass round out our trio of targets. pound for pound, they're some of the hardest fighting fish in the lake. Ontario's smallies can easily push past 5 pounds, with some real giants in the 7-8 pound range. They love rocky structure and will hit both live bait and artificial lures with gusto. When a big smallie decides your walleye bait looks tasty, you're in for a treat - they pull like freight trains and don't know when to quit.

Why Anglers Keep Coming Back

Look, I've been guiding on these waters for years, and there's a reason folks book trip after trip with us. It's not just about catching fish - though we do plenty of that. It's about that moment when your rod doubles over and your heart starts racing. It's watching the sun set over the lake while you're locked in battle with a fish you can barely turn. It's the stories you'll tell for years about "the one that didn't get away." Every trip is different, every fish is a new challenge, and that's what keeps it exciting, trip after trip.

Time to Book Your Spot

So, are you ready to test your skills against Lake Ontario's trophy walleye? Our evening charters fill up fast, especially during peak season. Whether you're a seasoned angler looking to add a wall-hanger to your collection or a newcomer hoping to experience the thrill of big-water fishing, we've got you covered. Bring your camera, bring your game face, and let's get out there and make some memories. The fish are waiting - all that's missing is you. Give us a call or hit that "Book Now" button. Trust me, your future self will thank you when you're posing with that monster walleye!

Learn more about the species

Northern Pike

Northern Pike are the ambush predators of Lake Ontario. These sleek, toothy fish can grow up to 4 feet long, though most run 2-3 feet. You'll find them lurking in weedy areas and along drop-offs, waiting to strike. Pike are most active in cooler water, so spring and fall are prime times. They put up an impressive fight when hooked, making powerful runs and acrobatic jumps. Anglers love targeting pike for their aggressive strikes and the challenge of landing such a strong fish. To entice a bite, try slow-trolling large minnow baits or spoons near weed edges. Just be careful when handling them - those razor-sharp teeth are no joke! Pike make for good eating too, with firm white flesh, though they can be bony. Overall, hooking into a big northern is always an exciting part of a day on Lake Ontario.

Northern Pike

Smallmouth Bass

Smallmouth Bass are the scrappy fighters of Lake Ontario. These bronze-colored fish typically run 2-4 pounds, though trophy catches can top 6. You'll find them around rocky points, shoals, and underwater structures in 5-30 foot depths. Smallies are most active in warmer months, with peak fishing from June through September. They're known for their acrobatic leaps and powerful runs when hooked. Anglers love targeting smallmouth for their aggressive strikes and pound-for-pound fighting ability. To entice a bite, try working tube jigs or drop shot rigs along rocky areas. A local tip: on calm days, look for smallies "busting" bait on the surface and cast topwater lures their way. The excitement of a smallmouth blasting a surface bait is hard to beat. They're also excellent table fare, with firm, white meat. A day chasing Lake Ontario smallies is always action-packed.

Smallmouth Bass

Walleye

Walleye are the prized catch of Lake Ontario, known for their tasty white fillets and challenging nature. These golden-olive fish average 2-3 pounds but can reach over 10. You'll find them along rocky structures and drop-offs, often in 15-30 foot depths. Walleye feed most actively at dawn and dusk, making evening trips ideal. They put up a stubborn fight when hooked, with powerful head shakes. Anglers love walleye for their delicious meat and the skill needed to consistently catch them. To up your odds, try slow-trolling with bottom bouncers and nightcrawler harnesses. Keep your bait near the bottom where walleye lurk. The satisfaction of landing a big 'eye, especially in low light conditions, is hard to beat. Plus, there's nothing like fresh walleye for dinner after a successful trip on the big lake.

Walleye
Tin Missile Trophy Sportsfishing

Follow Us

Facebook

Navigate

Home

Trips & Rates

Gallery

Reviews

Fishing Reports

Target Species

Meet the Captain

FAQ

Contact Us

FEATURED

Things To Do

NY River Catch

Walleye Chase

Lake Fun

Lake Trophy Hunt

Offshore Thrill

Fish Lake Ontario Like A Pro!

Discover Unrivaled Fishing Adventures with Tin Missile Trophy Sportsfishing by Captain Brian Swartz. Immerse yourself in unparalleled fishing excursions led by Captain Brian Swartz with Tin Missile Trophy Sportsfishing. Explore prime fishing locations, reel in trophy catches, and experience the joy of angling at its finest.

More about Tin Missile Trophy Sportsfishing

© Copyright 2025. All rights reserved.

Powered by Guidesly

Privacy Policy

Sitemap